骑兵用手榴弹破方阵步兵，可行不？

soul

那时手榴弹的技术不过关。另外考虑过没有投掷距离？可靠的投掷距离似乎是排枪范围内？

jesuisfabrice

骑兵最大的优势就是速度与冲击力。如果要扔手雷的话，势必减速，方阵一排枪打过来就全躺了

一等新兵

我只在架空小说里看过类似内容，而且那对付的还是缺乏火力的长枪兵方阵
你这个从本质上就是骑兵和步兵比火力，在黑火药时代可行性很小

戈培尔

倒不如用步兵手榴弹打骑兵
哈哈
这个东西不好说啊

最后的尼采

黑火药引燃线在拿破仑时代是个很值得讨论的话题，引燃技术在当时对比以前是否有进步？这种进步是否能支持骑兵掷弹？我想起了《风之谷》漫画中帝国骑兵的掷弹场景。。。

如果引燃技术不过关，那么往往会发生的就是扔出去的炸药再被步兵扔回来，那样对于骑兵更惨——因为只要有人和马二者之一被炸伤，一个骑兵战斗单元就失去效力了。

然而，问题的最关键是：你无法解决马上点火问题

vincentkeh

当时应该还没有发明火柴吧··？？那能不能用当时步枪上的燧发机关来引燃手雷上的引线呢？至于会不会被步兵扔回来，按照当时榴弹的射击，是根据发射距离长短来剪裁引线长度的原理，可以预先确定手雷引线的长度，现在手雷在老兵手里，也是拉开保险后，停留两秒再扔出去的`~

iron duke

步枪上的燧发机关是一个火石打火装置，需要把火药倒进药池，击发引燃。点燃手雷引信可以，需要先保证弹膛无子弹，再取枪，药池倒进火药，左手单手持枪，右手把手雷药捻凑到药池内，击发(这时不能颠簸，否则前功尽弃)，扔出。可是这是在阵前30码，弹雨纷飞，马不可能那么老实。手雷怕有一小半要落自己脚下，还有部分点火失败。
仍出的造成伤害也很有限，“光荣革命”时代手雷用过，发挥威力需要“直接命中”。
n 1643, it is possible that "Grenados" were thrown amongst the Welsh at Holt Bridge during the English Civil War. The word "grenade" originated in the Glorious Revolution (1688), where cricket ball-sized iron spheres packed with gunpowder and fitted with slow-burning wicks were first used against the Jacobites in the battles of Killiecrankie and Glen Shiel. These grenades were not very effective (probably because a direct hit would be necessary for the grenade to have effect)

装甲掷弹熊

俄国在七年战争中使用过掷弹骑兵，但他们在掷弹时依然是下马投掷，这更像是投弹兵的龙骑兵版本（被萨克森军官称为龙骑兵之花）
Six further regiments of dragoons were trans- formed into mounted grenadiers, with rather more success. The Commission hoped for great things of them, for no other army had anything of the kind, and a Saxon officer testifies that the grenadiers were 'the flower of the dragoons', though almost as badly mounted as the rest.
……
On campaign, however, they were to consider the employment of their special attribute, the grenade, of which every man carried two in a pouch. It was thought likely that in East Prussia the main resistance would be offered by hussars and peasants in uniform, who might try to hold out in buildings or behind other cover. In such an event the grenadiers were to dismount and cast their grenades inside the strongpoint, where the explosions would work to devastating effect in the confined space.

勒费弗尔元帅

我觉得似乎步兵扔手榴弹比较好吧

tjdx2006

不如，跟进几队炮兵。