iron duke 发表于 2015-5-31 23:21 
席勒失败了两次争议不太大，但梯也尔的５，６次看来还是比较夸张。按阿德金说法，两次攻击主攻都是希勒的 ...
Whilst the 1st Battalion of the 2nd Chasseurs were throwing themselves against the Prussians, the 1st Battalion [he should have said the 2nd] of the 2nd Grenadiers, under the orders of Lieutenant Colonel Golzio, received the order to support it. The emperor, perhaps anxious of Bülow’s offensive, entered Colonel Golzio’s square and personally gave particular orders for the attack; ‘do not fire a shot, but fall on the enemy with the bayonet’. This battalion immediately deployed out of square, changed direction to the right and found itself faced by a hedge which separated it from the Prussians. 4
Field, Andrew (2012-10-24). Waterloo: The French Perspective: (Kindle Locations 3948-3952). Pen and Sword. Kindle Edition.
看来分两次也不是没可能
不过感觉普村没人不太可能，因为第五团的团长就是死那里的。另外普方的报告都是说他们攻入了村子，缴获了火炮，然后再被“老”近卫军反击给赶出来的。
‘The open space around the churchyard，’ wrote Hiller,
was circled by houses and hedges from which the enemy, despite our every
courageous effort, could not be dislodged... Only the arrival of several fresh
masses of Old Guard made the men waver and, despite all my efforts, and
those of the brave officers supporting me, fall back.
|
楼主: 拉摩的侄儿
楼主
发表于 2015-5-31 23:21:28
