原帖由 thorongil 于 2008-2-29 17:09 发表 
没有，原因是日本人打的是海战，而马萨诸塞打的是靶子
请兄再仔细读读先前我与铁公爵兄的讨论，马萨诸塞是20节航速的时候开炮命中率达6%，日本人打靶是20节航速移动的时候打的吗？
北角海战，公爵对沙恩取得较多的命中是在后者被驱逐舰围困，并且速度下降之后才取得的，之前的较量，沙恩明显获得了比对手明显多的跨射次数。需要说明的是：沙恩的作战环境，是素来以能见度不好，海况恶劣影响观测的北极海域，并且时间是冬季，可以说是北极海一年中能见度最差的时节。从沙恩本身说，出航前本身的水兵素质下滑就已经相当严重，不得不从提尔皮茨抽调一些老兵，而且该舰的雷达很快在和英国巡洋舰的交战中被摧毁，所以后来完全是以光学指挥打击。更何况，在和公爵战斗后不久，就遭到了其他英舰的围攻，骚扰，必然影响到正常发挥；此外，公爵的火力足以更胜沙恩一个档次，话说回来，即使公爵没有比沙恩更好的雷达，火力上明显的优势也足以战胜。
北角海战，约克公爵号依靠雷达，在沙恩霍斯特号未察觉的情况下接近12000码，然后放出照明弹。无须别舰帮助校正，首轮齐射命中，直接打掉了沙恩霍斯特号的RADAR CONTROL。
http://hmsbelfast.iwm.org.uk/server.php?show=nav.00e004005
Shortly after gaining radar contact, the Duke of York succeeded in hitting the German battle cruiser with her first salvo.
还有沙恩霍斯特级专站的讲述
http://www.scharnhorst-class.dk/scharnhorst/history/scharnostfront.html
Scharnhorst aft position radar, the only one still working did not picked up Force 2 presence and this allowed the British battleship to come rapidly very close to the German battleship.
Distances now were rapidly decreasing between an unaware blind Scharnhorst and a powerful well radar equipped Duke of York that was fine tuning her main guns with the Type 284 artillery radar detection and pointing system.
The trap now was perfectly close, and Scharnhorst was in the middle of it.
Duke of York turned on course 080° to allow all of her main armament guns (10 by 356 mm) to be used against the enemy.
At 16:47, Admiral Fraser ordered Belfast to open fire with star shells from 17.500 meters, at 16:50 the starboard side 133 mm guns of Duke of York did the same from 11.000 meters, Scharnhorst got illuminated and was caught by surprise and unprepared especially by the presence of heavy ships between her track to south and Norway.
Duke of York thundered her 356 mm main guns broadside and Jamaica joined in, Scharnhorst got hit with first salvo and immediately reacted firing at Duke of York and Jamaica, turned to east and than to north increasing speed to the maximum. |
楼主: thorongil
发表于 2008-2-29 23:50:28
下图里黑线为美战列舰，C为川内，E为雾岛-雾岛有被萨沃岛遮蔽或干扰的时间。
楼主